Shoppers expect checkout to “just work.” In 2025, the best payment gateways for e-commerce combine fast approvals, global coverage, flexible wallets, and bulletproof fraud controls—without wrecking your margins or your UX. This guide cuts through marketing buzz to help you pick a gateway that fits your store’s size, regions, and risk profile, and shows you how to implement it cleanly so conversion—and trust—go up from day one.
Best payment gateways for online stores (2025 selection criteria)
- Coverage and methods: cards (Visa/Mastercard/Amex), digital wallets (Apple Pay, Google Pay), local methods (iDEAL, Bancontact, Boleto), BNPL, bank transfers, and recurring payments.
- Approval rates and reliability: low latency processing, smart retries, and network tokens for higher success.
- Fraud and risk: machine-learning fraud tools, 3-D Secure 2, dispute workflows, and fine-grained rules.
- Operational fit: multi-currency settlement, payouts cadence, unified reporting, and clean refunds/partials.
- Developer and platform fit: modern APIs/SDKs, platform plugins (WooCommerce/Shopify/BigCommerce), webhooks, and sandbox quality.
- Compliance and security: PCI DSS, SCA/3DS2 support, PSD2, and data residency options where required.
- Total cost of ownership: fees structure, cross-border and FX handling, dispute management, and engineering time.
Quick picks summary (who wins where)
- Stripe: best all-around for global SaaS/DTC with developer-first tools and wallets.
- PayPal: must-have button for trust and conversion, plus PayPal Pay Later—pair with another gateway.
- Adyen: enterprise-grade global acquiring with sophisticated risk and network optimization.
- Braintree: flexible PayPal-owned option with strong vaulting and marketplace tools.
- Shopify Payments: simplest path for Shopify stores; tight fraud, Shop Pay, and fast checkout.
- Square: in-person + online for SMBs; great if you also sell in-store or at events.
- Authorize.net: reliable legacy gateway for US merchants who want a classic setup.
- Checkout.com: modern enterprise gateway with broad local methods and solid reporting.
How we evaluated (methodology)
- Merchant profiles: SMB DTC, mid-market e-commerce, subscription SaaS, and omnichannel retailers.
- Regions: North America, EU/UK, LATAM, and APAC with priority on local methods.
- Scenarios: one-time checkout, subscriptions, pre-orders, split shipments, and refunds.
- Signals: implementation depth (APIs, SDKs, webhooks), ecosystem (plugins), fraud controls, reporting, and ops tooling.
- We do not list prices without verified sources. Always confirm fees on official pricing pages before selecting a gateway.
Detailed reviews (what’s great, where they fit, what to watch)
Stripe
Stripe remains a top choice for modern e-commerce and subscriptions. It supports major cards, Apple/Google Pay, Link, and a wide array of local payment methods. Developers love its API design, event-driven webhooks, strong docs, and testing tools. Fraud protection with Radar, network tokens, and smart retries help approvals. Subscriptions, metered billing, and customer portals are mature.
Best for: DTC, SaaS, multi-region brands that want velocity and A/B room on checkout UX.
Watch outs: Ensure you understand cross-border, currency conversion, and dispute workflows for your mix. Confirm fees on Stripe’s official pricing page.
Official docs: Stripe Docs • Pricing (verify)
PayPal
PayPal’s brand trust lifts conversion, especially for new shoppers and international buyers. PayPal Checkout adds an express path; PayPal Pay Later can raise AOV in some verticals. It pairs well with another gateway to cover card processing and alternative methods.
Best for: Adding trust, fast express checkout, and access to PayPal’s user base.
Watch outs: Reconcile fees and settlement across currencies. Make sure you configure webhooks and dispute management for visibility.
Official docs: PayPal Checkout Docs • Merchant fees (verify)
Adyen
Adyen offers unified global acquiring with excellent local method coverage and advanced risk controls. Large retailers and marketplaces value its reporting depth, optimization features, and support for complex operations (store + online, regional routing, tokenization).
Best for: Enterprise/mid-market brands operating across many countries and channels.
Watch outs: Implementation and contracts are typically enterprise-grade; ensure your volume and complexity justify the investment.
Official docs: Adyen Docs • Pricing overview (verify)
Braintree
Braintree (by PayPal) combines flexible card processing with native support for PayPal, digital wallets, and vaulting. It’s a solid choice for subscriptions and marketplaces needing split payouts and strong tokenization.
Best for: Brands that want PayPal ecosystem benefits plus a developer-friendly gateway.
Watch outs: Confirm settlement, dispute processes, and any cross-border implications based on your product mix.
Official docs: Braintree Docs • Pricing (verify)
Shopify Payments
If you’re on Shopify, Shopify Payments is the simplest, most integrated path: Shop Pay accelerated checkout, native fraud tools, and tight refund/reporting flows. You also get easy access to wallets and local methods based on region.
Best for: Shopify stores that want minimal setup friction and a fast, trusted checkout (Shop Pay).
Watch outs: Availability varies by country; confirm supported payment methods and fees for your region.
Official docs: Shopify Payments Help
Square
Square shines for merchants who sell online and in person. Its ecosystem connects POS, invoicing, and online checkout, simplifying inventory and customer data. If you run pop-ups, fairs, or a retail location, Square reduces operational overhead.
Best for: SMBs with omnichannel needs and lightweight development requirements.
Watch outs: Check supported countries, e-commerce platform integrations, and any additional costs for advanced features.
Official docs: Square Docs • Fees overview (verify)
Authorize.net
Authorize.net is a long-standing gateway favored by US merchants who prefer a classic setup with robust reliability, simple virtual terminal options, and broad cart plugins. Good fit for teams who need a familiar operational model.
Best for: Established US stores with straightforward needs and legacy ecosystem ties.
Watch outs: Confirm modern wallet/local method coverage if you’re expanding internationally.
Official docs: Authorize.net Developer Center • Pricing (verify)
Checkout.com
Checkout.com is a modern enterprise gateway with strong global coverage, local methods, and analytics. It’s popular with fast-scaling DTC and marketplace companies looking for flexibility and rigorous reporting.
Best for: Mid-market to enterprise brands that need breadth of methods and data visibility.
Watch outs: Align your regions and volumes to access the best features and support tiers.
Official docs: Checkout.com Docs • Pricing (verify)
Cost structures explained (without unverified numbers)
- Base processing: typically a variable percentage plus a fixed component per transaction—varies by card type, region, and product.
- Cross-border and FX: extra charges may apply when issuer and acquirer differ or currency conversion is needed.
- Alternative methods: some local methods carry different fee models; verify per method and market.
- Chargebacks/disputes: gateways may charge dispute fees; understand workflows and evidence timelines.
- Payouts: confirm payout schedules, minimums, and any instant payout options and costs.
Action item: always validate fees on official pricing pages for your region, product type, and volumes before deciding.
Implementation tips (ship a clean, fast checkout)
- Offer the right methods: enable Apple/Google Pay and the top local method(s) per country you serve.
- Use tokenization and network tokens: reduce declines on reissued or expired cards.
- Optimize 3DS2: use frictionless flows where possible; challenge only where risk is high.
- Instrument webhooks: log payment_intent events, refunds, disputes, and subscription updates for a reliable ledger.
- Design for retries: smart retries and backup rails raise approval rates without confusing customers.
- Keep checkout light: minimal fields, clear error states, and real-time validation.
- Reconcile end-to-end: ensure order, payment, and fulfillment systems stay in sync (especially with partial shipments or pre-orders).
Helpful builds on Isitdev: CRM Webhooks (2025) • Lead Routing (2025) • Appointment Scheduling (2025) • Automated Email Journeys
Platform notes (WooCommerce, Shopify, BigCommerce)
- WooCommerce: choose gateways with official extensions, strong webhook support, and refund sync. Host on fast PHP stacks and enable object caching to keep checkout snappy.
- Shopify: Shopify Payments offers the simplest path; if you use a third-party gateway, validate supported features and methods per country.
- BigCommerce: confirm native integrations for your gateway and check support for multi-currency, local methods, and saved cards.
Setting up or upgrading your store infrastructure?
Launch a fast WooCommerce store on Hostinger Browse high‑converting e‑commerce themes on Envato
Future outlook (what’s next in 2025)
- Local rails expand: bank transfers and account-to-account payments mature in more markets with improved UX.
- Wallet dominance: Apple/Google Pay adoption continues; expect more 1-click and network token enhancements.
- Real-time payouts: faster merchant settlements help cash flow-sensitive DTC brands.
- Risk + AI: adaptive risk models blend consented behavioral signals with device intelligence for fewer false declines.
How to choose a payment gateway (step-by-step)
- List your regions and top local methods you must support.
- Map your products: one-time vs subscriptions, pre-orders, split shipments.
- Define KPIs: approval rate, checkout speed, refund latency, dispute win rate.
- Shortlist 3 gateways that natively support your regions + methods.
- Run sandbox tests: wallets, 3DS2 flows, webhooks, and refunds.
- Model costs: validate official fee pages for cards, local methods, FX, and disputes.
- Pilot in one region: A/B wallets first; monitor approvals and drop-off.
- Harden: instrument retries, dispute workflows, and reconciliation.
- Scale: add regions/methods and revisit risk rules quarterly.
Final recommendations
- Enable wallets and the top local method per market before anything else; it’s the fastest lift.
- Pick one primary gateway and add PayPal as a trust booster if your audience expects it.
- Instrument webhooks and disputes on day one; evidence and visibility prevent revenue leaks.
- Review approval and dispute metrics monthly; tune 3DS2 and fraud rules with data.
Frequently asked questions
Which payment methods should I enable first?
Apple Pay and Google Pay plus the top local method in each country you sell to. Add PayPal if your audience expects it.
Do I need more than one gateway?
Often yes: one primary for cards/local methods and a PayPal button for trust and coverage. Some brands add a backup gateway for resilience.
How do I raise approval rates?
Use network tokens, smart retries, optimized 3DS2, and reduce checkout friction. Monitor issuer-specific declines.
What about subscriptions?
Choose a gateway with mature billing, proration, dunning, and webhooks for lifecycle updates.
How do I compare fees accurately?
Verify on official pricing pages for your region and methods. Include cross-border, FX, dispute fees, and payout schedules in your model.
Are BNPL options worth it?
They can lift AOV in some verticals. Test carefully; account for fees and potential return behavior.
Will 3-D Secure hurt conversion?
Frictionless 3DS2 keeps good traffic smooth. Challenge only higher-risk attempts; tune with data.
What’s the fastest way to start?
Enable wallets, integrate your primary gateway’s hosted elements, wire webhooks, and run a two-week pilot in one region.
How do I manage disputes?
Turn on alerts, standardize evidence templates, and measure win rates. Reduce friendly fraud with clear descriptors and receipts.
Where do I confirm supported methods?
On each gateway’s official docs and country availability pages. Always verify per market before launching.
Official resources to verify capabilities and pricing:
Stripe Docs • PayPal Merchant Fees • Adyen Docs • Braintree Docs • Shopify Payments Help • Authorize.net Developer • Checkout.com Docs
Disclosure: Some links are affiliate links. If you purchase through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Always verify fees and features on official vendor sites.
